Recovering Damages for Lost Income: The Calculation Can Be Complex

Lost Income Damages Can Be a Complex Part of Your Injury Claim

If you’ve sustained injuries from a motor vehicle accident caused by another person that affected your ability to earn an income, you are entitled to recover compensatory damages. This includes compensation for income lost because you were recuperating from your injuries.  These are lost income damages.  It also include compensation

Calculating Compensatory Damages for Lost Income Damages

for a loss of future earning capacity. For example, a surgeon who was in a car accident that affected the nerves in his hand might not be able to operate on patients due to a lack of motor control. A college professor with lingering memory issues after an accident may no longer be able to teach students effectively. These people can be awarded compensation for income lost both during recovery as well as long after the accident.

When discussing compensation related to lost income damages, it’s important to consider that damages aren’t calculated based on actual earnings before or after the injury. Damages are calculated based on the plaintiff’s ability to potentially earn money. The concept in the law is called lost earning capacity.  This means that you would be eligible to receive compensatory damages even if you were unemployed at the time of the accident. With this approach to calculating damages, a mother who had taken time off to care for her new baby with plans to return to work once her child is in preschool would not find her ability to seek compensatory damages limited by her current lack of paid employment.

Proving Earning Capacity

To prove earning capacity, your attorney may submit copies of your past income tax returns as well as information about employment you’ve held in the past along with the current job market for these types of positions. If you’re self-employed, your attorney may use estimates of what you’d make if you did similar work for someone else or what it would cost to hire someone to perform your duties at your company. Often preparing these calculations is a complex tax.  Your attorney may work with an expert such as a Certified Public Accountant or an economist to prepare a fair and accurate calculation.

Limits on Damages

A plaintiff does not need to be completely disabled to receive compensation for loss of future earning.  The limitations caused by an accident must, however, have a direct impact on his or her ability to earn an income.  IN addition, compensatory damages may be reduced or limited if the plaintiff was found to have in some way contributed to the injury in question. This could refer to conduct during the accident itself, such as running a red light or texting while driving.  This is called “comparative responsibility” in Idaho law.

Conduct after the accident that would aggravate the injury, such as refusing to follow your healthcare provider’s treatment recommendations, can also reduce damages.  This is called a “failure to mitigate” damages in Idaho law.   Just because an insurance company claims comparative responsibility or a failure to mitigate exists does not mean they are right.   Insurance companies and and their hired defense attorneys often assert such claims even when they are completely bogus.

Contact Us

If you or someone you love has been seriously injured in a motor vehicle accident, call John Edwards or any of the other personal injury attorneys at Hepworth Holzer. Our lawyers specialize in car accident  and trucking injury cases, so please call us today at (208) 328-6998 for a free case review.

John Janis Avatar

John Janis

John has been with the firm since 1990. Like all partners in the firm, John is an AV® Preeminent™ Peer Review Rated Personal Injury Lawyer. . The AV rating is a peer review rating based upon esteem amongst the legal profession. John has had numerous honors bestowed on him by his peers in the legal community, including being selected for membership in respected national organizations, such as The American Board of Trial Advocates (ABOTA). In 2018, John was inducted as a fellow in the American College of Trial Lawyers, a prestigious organization in which membership is limited to no more than 1% of lawyers practicing in their home state. John has also served as President of the Idaho Trial Lawyers Association, and in 2015 was named Plaintiff’s Lawyer of the Year by Best Lawyers in America.

In addition to his trial practice, John is a frequent lecturer on trial skills and civil practice to attorneys in Idaho. He also maintains his commitment to the legal profession through service on various committees such as Committee to Revise the Idaho Civil Jury Instructions and the Idaho Rules of Evidence Committee. Most recently, John was appointed by the Idaho Supreme Court to serve on the Civil Justice Reform Committee.

John graduated with Honors from the University of Idaho School of Law in 1986, where he served as Executive Editor of the Idaho Law Review. He is admitted to practice in Idaho State Courts, the Federal District Court, and the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.

His legal acumen, self-effacing style, and presentation skill has resulted in John being a frequent lecturer for other lawyers on topics relating to civil trial practice. He has served the profession in helping revise the Idaho Jury Instructions, the Idaho Rules of Evidence, and the Rules of Civil Procedure through committee appointments from the Idaho Supreme Court. He is a member and past President of the Idaho Trial Lawyers Association, and is admitted to practice before the state courts, the federal district court, and the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals. John has also had substantial appellate experience, and been involved in a significant number of reported appellate decisions.

Leave a Reply